« The future of music, Part II | Main | And the web changes again… »

February 19, 2009

iPhone: learning to live with Telstra

It took Bleeding Edge two hours to realise we’d made a terrible mistake with our Apple iPhone plan.

We’d justified the iPhone on the basis that this column can’t ignore what is arguably the most significant trend in mobile phones for at least a decade — a trend which has even convinced major corporations which have consistently ignored the mobile phone market to develop iPhone-specific applications.

But what really convinced us was when the young woman sitting next to us at Alliance Francaise clicked on her iPhone screen, entered a word and showed us the translation while we were still thumbing through the Collins French-English Dictionary. She had hers installed as an iPhone app. Resistance, we knew, was futile.

We thought we’d considered everything when we walked into the mobile phone shop two days later. We’d be paying more for Telstra Next G network, but its coverage and robustness are peerless.

Telstra Mobile remains the one division of the national carrier that we still rate as superior to the competition, and impossible to detach from ... provided you’re on one of the genuine Next G capped plans hidden away here.

Unfortunately, there was only one iPhone cap plan — the Ultimate at $150 a month for a ridiculous 2000 minutes of calls and 2000 SMS messages per month. The other alternative was to buy the iPhone outright, and we weren’t enthusiastic about handing over $1200.

We’re pretty sure that’s why our thinking got scrambled in between walking into the store and putting our signature on the contract.

 

We convinced ourselves that we could get away with the $70 package, plus an additional data pack, which would double the allowance from 150MB to 300MB per month for a total of $89 per month. For that, we’d pay only an additional $179 for a 16GB iPhone over a two-year contract.

We should have been focusing on the call allowance, rather than the price of the iPhone and the data pack. The $60 phone plan we’d signed up for wouldn’t cover our typical calling pattern. The flag fall for each call was 27c, and each 30 second block would chew up another 28c — nowhere near the $49 monthly Next G cap of $200 in calls, plus $50 Telstra mobile calls, despite its 37c flag fall and 40c per 30 seconds.

The magnitude of our error began to sink in only after we’d realised that the media’s concentration on this device’s internet capabilities has tended to obscure the fact that it makes voice and texting operations so much simpler than the average smart phone. Once you get one into your hands you begin to understand what a true communications device it is, and you find yourself placing more calls and sending more SMS messages ... to say nothing of the iTunes AppsStore.

Financially, however, it looked like we were sunk. That was the point at which Bleeding Edge’s impossible optimism kicked in. Why not ring Telstra and ask them to change the plan? All we had to do was to convince Telstra to overlook that contract we’d signed.

It was Monday morning when we rang 125 111, and asked for the iPhone department. The customer service agent listened to our proposition, and told us that he’d put us through to someone who could help.

Our past experiences with Telstra has taught us to translate that as putting us through to someone who wouldn’t help. This time, we were surprised to find ourselves talking to someone who asked us for details of our complaint.

We explained that we hadn’t made a complaint, and we were rather hoping that we wouldn’t have to. We had been a customer of Telstra Mobile since its establishment and we could see no reason at all why Telstra would want to offend us.

He agreed, and explained that we’d been put through the wrong department. His department dealt with escalated complaints, but he’d put us through to the customer loyalty department.

The customer loyalty person didn’t sound very promising. This would be a problem, he mused, because we’d have to pay a termination fee of $979. And then there was the matter of having bought the phone from an independent, rather than a Telstra shop. “They have their own avenues of dealing with these issues,” he said.

Nevertheless, what he could do was put us on a $79 capped plan of $79 ($450 calls a month plus $100 calls to Telstra mobiles at 35c per 30 seconds) and drop our data pack back to $10 for 150MB per month. In four days we’d used no mobile data, because we’d been using wi-fi.

It was a much better deal for us, and it suggested that Telstra might possibly have discovered that treating its customers well was a better strategy than screwing them to a deal. Could the iPhone be improving their communications too?

Posted by cw at February 19, 2009 08:13 AM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://bleedingedge.com.au/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1689

Comments

This is my first comment on this site, indeed it's the first time I've been here. I read the column every week, though.

I, too, am a student at the Alliance Française de Melbourne. I'm surprised I haven't come across you there.

I'm interested in the electronic dictionary. When I follow the link, I see there are several French-English dictionaries. Can you please tell me which one it is?

Also, does it have a hard copy equivalent? The biggest dictionary I have at the moment is the single (very large) volume Collins Robert French-English; there's a bigger one in two volumes, but mine is the one below that. Do you know where the electronic one fits in relation to that?

Also again, the entries in my dictionary are very long, with examples given of all (or most) of the manners in which a word can be used, so that it's very useful for English-French translations. Is the electronic one as good as that?

I don't have an iPhone, and I probably won't buy one until the next generation comes with 30+GB of memory, so it can replace my trusty iPod as well as the Motorola. If the dictionary is a real goer, that'll probably tip me over the edge to buy one.


Posted by: Spectator at February 19, 2009 10:08 PM

I'm not sure which version it is, but I doubt it's quite as comprehensive as the Robert. It's very useful, however, to be able to do a quick lookup on the iPhone.

I noticed somewhere however that if you've got a recent copy of the hardback version there's a number that allows you to get the online subscription service free.

I'm doing one of the morning courses at Alliance Francaise. It's a very busy place. Scarcely room to fit my motor scooter into the car park!

Posted by: cw at February 19, 2009 10:46 PM

Many thanks, Bleeding Edge.

It sounds as if it's good to have when trying to read a French novel and an unknown word crops up (as they tend to do frequently), but not really for English-French translations. I think that's probably good enough for me.

I've been going to the AFM for a few years now. I started doing the Beginners courses on Saturday mornings, which are excellent because you can progress very rapidly, but I got to the end of all that and had to change to evenings, which are not nearly so convenient.

I really like the place, though.

Posted by: Spectator at February 20, 2009 08:54 AM

If I could turn my images off on Safari on the Iphone it wouldnt be an issue - I kept my data usage extremely low on my Nokia that way - and I assumed that Iphone would have a similar ability.. nope.

Posted by: Sarah at November 27, 2009 11:06 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?



(you may use HTML tags for style)