« Extremely remote control | Main | Flickr is having a massage! »

May 24, 2007

Content-driven fitness

Your personal trainers at the Bleeding Edge fitness centre would like to introduce you to the latest exercise routine developed by our staff, built around a couple of devices that are more demanding than any Stairmaster: the HTPC and the PVR.

Yes folks, the Home Theatre PC and the personal video recorder will have you running from one room to the other, in a continuous search for content. You may be aware of our innocent entry into content-driven circuit training, with the arrival, a few years ago, of our first media centre, based on the Linux world’s MythTV.

In those days, we simply wanted some way of recording free-to-air TV to hard disk, so that we could watch our favourite programs on our schedule, rather than that of the networks. The first generations of these products were more personal computer than home theatre, limited by factors like size, noise and power consumption, so eventually we moved to the Topfield TF5000PVRt, which, with the addition of small programs called TAPs, such as the brilliant ProgressBarKeys developed by Perth-based Andy Cullen, delivered much of the functionality of a PC to what was essentially a member of the familiar audio-visual player/recorder product family, like the VCR and the DVD.

How could we have known then that we were acquiring an insatiable hunger that would lead us into ever more strenuous exertions?

Regular readers will have picked up the first clues when we started writing about BitTorrent, the peer-to-peer file transfer program that allowed us to download programs from the US and the UK, and view them within a day or so of their appearance in New York or London. We had become multimedia citizens of the global village.

The only problem was that we needed a Windows PC or a Mac to download those programs, and they were in the home office, or the Bleeding Edge cave at the Abbotsford Convent, rather than in the lounge room with the television set. We’d discovered a regular routine for accelerating the heart rate.

At the same time, we had been accumulating a vast library of MP3 music files, which were also on our computers. The 2nd generation iPod made it relatively portable. As the collection expanded, we bought a 3rd generation and then a 4th generation iPod. At the same time we became hooked on podcasts – mostly from ABC Radio National and the BBC – and we used the SanDisk Sansa to manage them.

What we noticed, however, was that whenever we wanted to play the iPod or Sansa through the lounge room Hi-Fi, we’d have to first trek around the house, playing hide and seek. Had we used it in the bedroom last night? Or was it in the car? The office? A bag?

Last week, when the first gorgeous Bleeding Edge granddaughter – “Hello Indigo” – suddenly appeared on the scene, we realised things were about to get completely out of hand. Grandchildren generate vast amounts of still and video images – who knows, possibly even podcasts? - and we’d already experienced missing slideshow syndrome, where the images you want to screen on the TV aren’t where you need them to be, right now, before your prospective audience gets bored and starts making excuses to leave.

This brings us to something of a crisis point. Frankly there are more interesting ways of maintaining fitness, so we’re going to have to replace the Topfield with something that gives us the ability to tap our central stores of video, audio and images, without domestic excursions.

We thought briefly about the recently-released high-definition version of the Topfield, the TF7000HT, but the Korean manufacturers have not only overlooked the first requirement of an up-to-date PVR – wireless or Ethernet capability – they’ve also apparently lost touch with reality. They’ve concentrated all their efforts on high-definition resolution, and overlooked the fact that the “upgrade” eliminates the features that made their products so popular. The TF7000HT costs $1100, but it doesn’t accommodate TAPs, and more critically, can’t handle the Ice TV electronic program guide ($90 per annum from icetv.com.au) that we in the fitness centre regard as essential for the prevention of exercise-related stress. While an upgraded firmware is expected to restore the EPG capability, there’s no indication yet that it will work with TAPs.

A couple of weeks ago, however, the local distributors released a competing device, the Beyonwiz DP-S1, which has dual high-definition tuners, meaning you can record two channels, and watch a pre-recorded show, a DVD player, and a 200GB hard drive. We’d have liked to see a 400GB drive, given the size of HD files, and the $1500 price tag, but the fact that it has wireless and Ethernet networking makes on-board storage less critical. We can hook it up remotely to our computer content stores – fortunately, a few years ago we laid an Ethernet cable to our lounge room.

The Beyonwiz has codecs to handle all the popular compressed video and audio formats, and while it doesn’t yet have the programming interface to deliver the functionality of TAPs, it’s based on Linux, and could gain them.
You can plug in external USB 2.0 storage devices, and still or video cameras. You can even slide in a Compact Flash, SD or MMC card into slots in the front panel and play your content from there.

The question it raises is one that a lot of multimedia work-out fanatics will be asking themselves: is a device like this a better or worse investment than an HTPC – the Windows Media Centre or the Mac mini for example.
Although you can do more with a computer, do you really need to have another one in your lounge room? The Beyonwiz is likely to have a much faster start-up time, and will be much simpler to operate and fit out than a computer. And it’s not likely to suffer from the irritating bug that has infected some – but not all - Windows Vista Media Centre installations in Australia: the sudden regular disappearance of Channel 7 and SBS and the IceTV program guide.

Over the next month or so, we hope to answer some of those questions. Once we recover from the muscle cramps.

Posted by cw at May 24, 2007 04:01 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://bleedingedge.com.au/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1300

Comments

I own a Toppy 5000 and have found a way to compliment it with an additional cheap box with comprehensive media capabilities. It is the X Box Media Centre. Buy a used X-Box Mk I ($150). Chip it and put in a big H.D. ($170). Install the free open source XBMC application. The X Box chipping person can do all this for you but make sure they install the latest stable release (2.0.1).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/XBMC
http://www.xboxmediacenter.com/

It gets on the network, can find any kind of networked media library and plays anything video or audio. It also does a nice picture slide show. All media can be scanned into a D.B. for proper browsing. It interrogates allmusicguide.com and imdb.com to add reviews and thumbnails to your media library. People write python scripts for it so you can browse youtube. It receives shoutcast internet radio. It has a web server so it can be controlled remotely.

It is fantastic and a great source of joy to me! I shall be happy for some time with my X box and
Toppy 5000.

Posted by: Steven Armstrong at June 3, 2007 06:12 PM

I also use Xbox Media Center with great satisfaction.

It plays .iso DVD images, streams Dolby Digital to the 5.1 speakers in the lounge room, and because my iTunes library is in a shared folder, I can listen to all of my music in the living room.

It's the perfect, cheap 10 foot interface.

Posted by: tony at June 8, 2007 05:47 PM

I have XBMC as well.
IT IS THE BEST MEDIA CENTER OUT THERE.
A MUST HAVE.
cons:
Takes time to set up (but well worth it!)
Need a little know how.
some scripts don't work (Youtube 1.8b)curse the creators for not fixing it.
pros:
plays practically all media including:
NES, SNES, Sega Genesis, Playstation 1, and of course xbox games, install trainers to make sure your the best gamer out there(lol I have fun with that), DVDs, Music of all types(.wav,.mp3,etc.), Streaming music off internet.

google around for xbmc and tutorials on how to install it. It's a good "buy" without the money part.

Posted by: something at July 2, 2007 04:42 AM

Post a comment




Remember Me?



(you may use HTML tags for style)